The Florida Bar rejected a recent round of professional misconduct complaints against former U.S. Attorney General Pam Bondi, according to records a Bar spokesperson sent me. The complaints accused her of pressuring Justice Department lawyers to violate their ethical obligations and personally defying court orders.
In a two-page letter to Bondi dated Oct. 16, the Bar said it found “insufficient evidence that your conduct violated the Rules of Professional Conduct.” It also cited First Amendment protections for political speech.
Bondi’s law license was issued in Florida, where she was twice elected attorney general as a Republican. The state Bar has the authority to investigate misconduct complaints against its members, including Bondi, and seek penalties ranging from reprimands to disbarment. The Florida Supreme Court has the final say on discipline.
The complaints included a May 27 filing jointly submitted by three legal organizations and supported by more than 120 retired judges, law professors and attorneys. That complaint said Bondi oversaw prosecutions brought without probable cause, including cases against protesters and Trump’s “political enemies.”
It also accused her of failing to protect the identities and privacy of Epstein abuse survivors. The complaint cited the Justice Department’s release of victims’ unredacted names and dates of birth, along with nearly 40 nude photographs of women, some of whom may have been underage.
The DOJ slammed the filing, telling the Miami Herald, “This complaint is nothing more than a baseless and pathetic media stunt conjured up by inept attorneys desperate for relevance.”
Bondi did not respond to my requests for comment.
Records show the Bar sent letters to more than 60 people nationwide who submitted complaints or inquiries about the former attorney general, telling them it had closed its file. Most were from outside Florida. The Bar’s letter to Bondi says it reviewed all inquiries it received from the public, as well as video footage of her interviews, statements and testimony, and “considered the allegations surrounding the release of the Epstein files.”
I asked Bar spokesperson Jennifer Krell Davis whether officials interviewed witnesses or obtained internal Justice Department records, and how they investigated allegations that Bondi pressured DOJ lawyers to violate ethics rules, beyond reviewing her public statements. She didn’t answer those questions.
Florida Bar Response to Pam Bondi Ethics Complaints by jmdglss
Allegations involving Justice Department attorneys
Retired Florida Supreme Court Chief Justice Peggy Quince submitted the May 27 complaint on behalf of Lawyers Defending American Democracy, Democracy Defenders Fund and Lawyers for the Rule of Law.
The 24-page filing accused Bondi of establishing a “fall-in-line-or-get-out” philosophy at the Justice Department, pressuring lawyers to pursue President Trump’s political objectives even when doing so violated their ethical obligations.
One of the main allegations concerned a memo Bondi sent Feb. 5, 2025, her first day as attorney general, titled “General Policy Regarding Zealous Advocacy on Behalf of the United States.” It said DOJ attorneys were responsible for “vigorously defending presidential policies and actions against legal challenges on behalf of the United States.” It warned that attorneys who, because of their “personal political views or judgments,” declined to sign briefs, appear in court or “advance good-faith arguments on behalf of the Administration” would be subject to “discipline and potentially termination.”
The coalition said the memo “presumes to override the independent legal judgment of individual attorneys,” pressuring DOJ lawyers to take positions that violated their ethical obligations.
The complaint cited several examples, including the suspension and firing of DOJ attorney Erez Reuveni after he told a federal judge about Kilmar Abrego Garcia’s deportation to El Salvador. A 2019 immigration judge’s order had barred his removal to that country. The Justice Department acknowledged the error, and U.S. District Judge Paula Xinis described his detention as “wholly lawless.”
The coalition also alleged that federal prosecutor Denise Cheung was forced to resign after refusing to open an investigation she believed lacked evidence. Danielle Sassoon and nearly a dozen other prosecutors quit over the Justice Department’s effort to dismiss corruption charges against New York City Mayor Eric Adams. The complaint said dropping the charges was part of a political deal. Bondi called the case “incredibly weak” and claimed it was brought to make deportations harder.
The coalition accused Bondi of creating “a coercive environment that supported unethical activity,” alleging that her memo and the actions of senior DOJ officials “set in motion measures designed to ensure that subordinates would violate their ethical obligations” whenever it served the administration’s priorities.
The complaint also accused Bondi of personally violating court orders and failing to stop violations by Justice Department attorneys she supervised. It cited the case of Lindsey Halligan. Bondi appointed her interim U.S. attorney for the Eastern District of Virginia, but after a judge ruled the appointment unlawful, Halligan kept using the title. When U.S. District Judge David Novak ordered her to explain why, she defended herself in a court filing that Bondi and Deputy Attorney General Todd Blanche signed on to. Novak said it contained “vitriol more appropriate for a cable news talk show” and found that Halligan was defying a binding court order. He called it “inconceivable” that the Justice Department would “repeatedly ignore court orders, while simultaneously prosecuting citizens for breaking the law.”
In immigration cases handled by DOJ lawyers, the complaint said Bondi failed to address widespread violations of court orders. Federal judges in Minnesota documented 210 violations by ICE. Chief U.S. District Judge Patrick Schiltz criticized Justice Department leadership for putting its attorneys in an “impossible position” without adequate resources to handle the flood of cases. He said he knew of no other time in U.S. history when a federal court had to threaten contempt “again and again and again” to force the government to comply. In New Jersey, the Justice Department’s own figures showed between 52 and 72 violations of court orders.
The coalition based its allegations on public records, court proceedings, government documents and news reporting. It asked the Bar to investigate Bondi’s personal knowledge of and responsibility for the alleged misconduct.
The May 27 complaint followed one filed in June 2025 by Florida attorney Jon May and a coalition of lawyers, former judges and legal organizations. The Bar declined to investigate it while Bondi was attorney general, citing its policy against investigating sitting federally appointed officials.
May challenged the Bar in the Florida Supreme Court, asking the justices to order an investigation, but they rejected his request. All seven justices serving at the time were appointed by Republican governors, as are all seven today.
After President Trump fired Bondi in April 2026, the coalition said it would file a new complaint repeating the original allegations and adding new ones.
In an April 2 interview, May said he had little hope the Bar would discipline Bondi, although he expected it to investigate.
“My goal was never to get her disbarred,” he told me.
Instead, he wanted to develop legal arguments federal judges could use to hold prosecutors and their supervisors accountable for misconduct.
Bar cites First Amendment protections
The Bar’s Oct. 16 letter says disciplinary action requires “clear and convincing” evidence of misconduct, a higher standard of proof than in an ordinary civil trial. It also says the Bar conducted a “thorough analysis” of whether Bondi’s statements were protected as political speech under the First Amendment.
Much of that discussion cites a July 9 Florida Supreme Court ruling in The Florida Bar v. Crowley. During his 2018 campaign for state attorney, lawyer Christopher Crowley was arrested on felony charges stemming from a fundraiser in Fort Myers, Florida, where he allegedly promoted an illegal raffle and violated campaign contribution laws. He repeatedly accused his opponent, Amira Fox, then the second-ranking prosecutor in the office he hoped to lead, of orchestrating his arrest, even though the case had been transferred to prosecutors in another judicial circuit.
A judge appointed to hear the Bar’s disciplinary case found that Crowley made statements about Fox knowing they were false or with reckless disregard for the truth, and recommended a 60-day suspension of his law license. The state Supreme Court rejected that recommendation, ruling that the First Amendment protected “vigorous, open debate” about the integrity of candidates. “This is true even where, as here, the speech is inaccurate, offensive, and misleading,” the court wrote.
Six Florida Supreme Court justices participated in the Crowley decision and ruled unanimously.
“No record of my complaint”
Justice Quince told me she called the Bar twice on Nov. 10 and was told it had no record of her May 27 complaint against Bondi, even though its records show it received the filing.
“She took my name and number and said the supervisor would call me, but no one called,” Quince wrote of the woman she spoke with.
On Oct. 15, Quince told me the complaint was still pending and being considered alongside other filings. She later said Bar employees gave her that information.
On Nov. 13, three days after Quince called the Bar, Davis, the organization’s spokesperson, sent me 276 pages of records. They included the Oct. 16 decision and a Nov. 5 letter addressed to Quince stating that the file was closed. But the packet did not include her May 27 complaint or the email submitting it.
Quince said she had received no communication from the Bar about its decision and learned of the dismissal from me.
After I questioned the missing records, the Bar provided a corrected 531-page packet on Nov. 16. It included the email Quince personally sent to the Bar at 2:42 p.m. on May 27 with the complaint attached.
“We apologize for the letter from Justice Quince not being in the original packet, that was an error,” Davis wrote.
Davis also said the Bar mailed closure notices on Nov. 5, including one addressed to Quince. That letter was sent to a Massachusetts post office box associated with Lawyers Defending American Democracy. Quince confirmed the address was listed on the complaint form.
Asked why Quince was reportedly told the Bar had no record of her complaint, Davis wrote, “We do not know who Justice Quince spoke to, and so cannot address that question.”
Quince said on Nov. 16 that no decision had been made about taking further action following the dismissal.